Challenge phases Main content User comments Concept's statistics and author info Related themes, inspirations and concepts Share concept Shallenge activity feed Footer links
Login

The Challenge

1372 followers

How might we restore vibrancy in cities and regions facing economic decline? Read the challenge brief

Concept

Connecting Abandoned Spaces with Community Needs

I agree that information visualization can play a significant role in the revitalization of Detroit. This concept outlines how activists in Detroit can engage community organization, youth, and open source data visualizations to articulate neighborhood needs.
A number of contributors to this challenge have noted that information visualization (informatics, mapping, data dashboards, etc.) can play a significant role in helping revitalize Detroit. I agree with this perspective and I'd like to share a concrete plan for how visualizations might be paired with local youth in an effort to identify a) abandoned buildings or lots and b) communities' spatial needs.

As noted in the Challenge Brief, the city of Detroit once supported 2.5 million people and is now home to 300,000 residents. The city is full of buildings and lots that are abandoned or in a state of significant disrepair. Efforts to "right-size" the city are underway, and I think that information visualization can make the job of understanding the scale of the problem and the potential solution much easier to comprehend.

Several projects are currently creating maps that illustrate the problem of vacant lots. Data Driven Detroit (D3), for instance, releases PDF maps and online tools that allow you to see the percentage of vacant buildings at several levels, from census tracts to individual addresses. I would argue that it is important to open this data even further, releasing the source data - which doesn't appear to be available on D3's site - so that others can extend the benefits of their data collection work. Other groups are also creating compelling visualizations: NPR recently released a census map (seen in this concept's screenshot) created by Development Seed that depicts population shifts down to the individual census tract. With this data in hand, city officials and neighborhood groups can understand the nature of the problem at a super local level, see how one neighborhood compares against another, and quickly understand trends over time.

The second piece of this concept involves engaging local youth to begin working with neighborhood leadership to determine what the neighborhood's greatest needs are. Several different kinds of spatial needs come to mind: recreational spaces (parks, paths, etc.), indoor spaces (community centers, training centers, libraries, etc.), and productive spaces (storefronts, small businesses, community gardens, etc.). Engaging youth and connecting them with neighborhood leadership has several advantages: youth will have a constructive activity to participate in; youth will develop a sense of investment in their communities; youth will develop advocacy skills; and youth will connect with their elder neighbors and therefore strengthen the social fabric in their neighborhoods. Documenting neighborhood needs should occur in a standardized way so that the data produced by youth can be integrated with the data tracking abandoned spaces and other neighborhood indicators. A number of tools for this purpose exist, including Local Ground, a paper-based mapping tool developed by Sarah Van Wart, a colleague at the University of California, Berkeley, that allows people to physically annotate paper maps and digitize them at a later time.

Paired together, these two data-driven pieces will help empower youth to tell the story of their neighborhoods and advocate for improvement. Shared with city leadership, they will help decision makers allocate resources to communities with the greatest need and in places where the community is willing to support community development activities.

Thanks for reading - I would love to hear from the openIDEO community on this idea.

What resources (money, time, people, technology, etc) will your concept need to be successful?

The key to this concept is youth engagement; it will not succeed if youth don't have incentives to participate. It will also be critical to secure the participation of city leadership so that participants in the initiative understand that the products of their efforts will be seen and considered by their local government. The time of both of these groups is required.

Individuals and groups familiar with community organization will be required to coordinate the efforts of youth and facilitate their interaction with civic leaders.

Training on the tools and techniques associated with data collection will be necessary, including any technologies used.

Technology costs should be quite low given that this could all be accomplished with open source tools like TileMill (for visualizing geographic data), Ushahidi (digital data collection), and Local Ground (paper-based data collection). A relatively small budget should be allocated for shared computer equipment, web hosting of shared data sets, and potentially some expert support.

What steps could you take to implement this idea today?

The first step would be to begin connecting with community organizers in Detroit to find strong partners and identify a small handful of target neighborhoods.

How can your idea be scaled so that it's implemented in cities around the world?

While grassroots development is by its nature very labor intensive and can be difficult to scale, if this idea were successful, it would be relatively easy to create a curriculum and toolkit of sorts for other cities and neighborhoods to follow.

Comments

Join the conversation and post a comment.

January 03, 2012, 05:52PM
Hi Paul, i missed your concept a few weeks back and posted along the same vein... http://www.openideo.com/open/vibrant-cities/concepting/community-resource-mapping-and-web-interface/

But thrilled to see your research and goals and look forward to discussing further.
December 19, 2011, 08:30AM
Hi Paul,
Though focused on public health, the BAVC Map Your World project might be worth looking at as a model for youth mapping of community needs. http://revolutionaryoptimists.org/map-your-world
I think they might have a partner or peer organization in Detroit, too.
December 11, 2011, 04:06PM
Paul this is a vital component in any successful realisation or implementation of redevelopment projects.While many of us envision particular ways to possibly enhance the aesthetics, environment or livability of a run down area it is essential that such initiatives fulfill a recognised community need.. The need might be as fundamental as shelter or as esoteric as performing arts space but nevertheless need is almost universally a driving force in development success.
Paul Goodman's reply to Michael Jones's comment
December 11, 2011, 08:27PM
Thanks for the comment, Paul. Totally agree that actual, on-the-ground needs should drive any of these concepts.
Paul Reader's reply to Michael Jones's comment
December 12, 2011, 12:02AM
I guess there are a few concepts that respond to implied need - Sarah Fathalla's Embellish the Ugly and marketing catch-cries like Vincent Cheng's Reclaim Detroit - but the initiatives that flow from these definitely require factual "need based" support. It's one of the reasons I like to look at how concepts fit together especially when it comes to refinement and evaluation. It is also where integrating existing initiatives may be helpful. Max Harper's idea for Community-based Training Academy for Urban Renewal built on the already existing Green Economy Leadership Training that could be leveraged to broaden its scope to participating in identifying the variety of needs - green sustainability yes but shelter, transport, health,education and other things too.
close

Login

Forgot my password?

New user? Sign up!