Challenge phases Main content User comments Inspiration's statistics and author info Related themes, inspirations and concepts Share inspiration Challenge activity feed Footer links
Login

The Challenge

1373 followers

How might we restore vibrancy in cities and regions facing economic decline? Read the challenge brief

Inspiration

Mission #4 Collect Insights Find out more...

Portraits from a Job Starved City

Rockford, IL is one of the worst hit US cities: unemployment reaching nearly 16 percent. The NY Times compiled audio interviews/photos of 24 people there: assembly worker, CEO, police sergeant, teacher, military recruiter, small business owner, etc.
I've identified some recurring themes & illustrated with notes on selected excerpts below ( View & Hear all their Stories by clicking here ):

Signs of Decline
  • "When people give directions, they always give directions of where things were...You go down to where Sears was and make a left..."
  • "I've seen a real shift in the type of people you see that are homeless these days...We've seen a lot of people become homeless because they've lost their jobs, they've lost their homes. We've seen a lot of families...They don't know how to work the system...where you go to eat, where you go for assistance...People who are newly homeless don't really have a clue."
  • "Quite often you would get the individuals who were struggling financially..they'd end up embezzling money or doing things of that nature...You could tell these were really good-hearted people that found themselves between a rock and a hard place. They'd come into an interview and start crying...they were sincerely apologetic, but...they felt they needed to do what they did to survive."
  • "The way things are going, I mean, I know it's gotta get better sooner or later, but this is the worst I've seen. If you ride along Rockford, you see a lot of abandoned factories. It's hard, I mean it's even hard for a man that works every single day."
  • "We lost a lot of teams bowling, a lot of people aren't drinking a lot as much as they used to and not tipping as much as they used to. They aren't eating dinner out as much as they used to...They're staying home and drinking."

Job Search Difficulties
  • "The hardest part was each day going out and hearing no over and over and over. And just wondering is there ever going to be anything, you know."
  • "I was unemployed 5 months. Every day I was on the computer sending resumes, but nothing ever seemed to stick."
  • "I think I applied to 19 places while I was still counting and I hadn't found anything, so it was pretty bad. Especially at the big box places where they have so many employees already, you're not really worth much at stores like that, you're kind of a dime a dozen"
  • "So when I got offered the job here, I actually had to leave my husband and come here. It was very difficult. He just graduated in December. And he's an electrical engineer. He's applying for jobs to be a manager at Home Depot. You do what you can. You can't just not have the income."

Job Security
  • "Coming to work every day, I feel like I'm contributing again. I'm able to pay my bills...or try to pay my bills. And I feel like I'm providing for myself again. I feel a sense worth again. This job has given me that."
  • "I'm on my feet all day. Lifting, bending, stooping, squatting. You know, it's like an 8 or 9 hour a day workout...I look at it this way. If you're good at what you do, and you're worth your salt, you do your job, you don't cause problems. You'll keep your job."
  • "I do my job to the best of my ability, but that belief was kind of racked, because last April I was one of the teachers who was pink slipped. Even despite having great evaluations, despite loving my job, having a wonderful principal who was very supportive of me, I still lost my job."
  • "What would possess you to do this, to take on this venture, and I say 'job security'. Because the one things I learned, having been with a company through all its growth and ups and downs over the course of 15 years, really at the end of the day in the corporate world I ended up feeling very much like a number on a page. I was no longer a person."
  • "Business aren't just going to come to Rockford. We have to go out and seek them."

Leaving a Sinking Ship
  • "A lot of my friends want to move somewhere else because they think Rockford is going down...and all the businesses are closing...We don't know what it's going to be like in a couple of years."
  • "It's kind of dead end sometimes in the area. You can't push very far. There's not really much to do. I'm looking to get out."

Staying For Community
  • "Every time I try to leave Rockford, it brings me back in. I love this community. I know that's not to say there aren't bad aspects to it...I just keep finding myself coming back to Rockford. There's a familiarity. It's my home. It's where I grew up. I'm loyal to the community that raised me, the community that kinda shaped my personality. The fact that I know the shortest way to get from the grocery store to the bowling alley..."
  • "I'm a Midwestern girl at heart and I love Rockford. I mean it has its perks and there's things that aren't that great about it, but it's never going to get better if everyone leaves. It's only going to get better if people actually stick down roots here, and are willing to invest their time and energy."
  • "I expected to retire from my 1st place. But they was closing up and moving out of town, so then it was time to, either I had to move or find something else...I think the main reason we're here is roots, family and friends. It'd be hard to just get up and leave and go somewhere else."
  • "6 months later Dan's company moved to Pennsylvania. We have 5 kids, so we definitely weren't picking up and moving to Pennsylvania."

Tempered Optimism
  • "Well for me, since I've lived here my entire life, it's easy for me to figure out, ok granted I've hit a rough patch, but I know I can overcome it. If I just keep my chin up and I keep working and I keep looking, I'm going to have something come forward."
  • "I try to be optimistic, but I'd rather have a lower standard and be delighted with the outcome, than have a high standard and be disappointed."
  • "I quit watching the news. The only news I watch is SportsCenter. That helps me stay oblivious and ignorant to the world outside."
Mission #4 Collect Insights Find out more...

Comments

Join the conversation and post a comment.

December 02, 2011, 01:29AM
This is such a powerful summary. It got me thinking about the "cycle of vibrancy" inspiration (http://www.openideo.com/open/vibrant-cities/inspiration/understanding-life-cycles-of-vibrancy-/) and if/how Rockford's current economic shift could be channeled to attract new forms of creativity, particularly among its youth.

Could there be policies to stimulate new businesses, for example, and what would have to be in place in terms of infrastructure and support to attract entrepreneurs or encourage current residents to take such chances?
November 30, 2011, 01:03AM
What a touching inspiration. Like Sarah, I was struck by the line "When people give directions, they always give directions of where things were". Not only does it speak to the actual decline of the city (shops closing), but it also powerfully demonstrates how people can become attached to the way things *were*.

It strikes me that the reverse is seen when people are optimistic about the future - think of a friend showing you around a new house they just bought, "this is where the nursery will be, this is where we'll put my study".
Vincent Cheng's reply to sushmita meka's comment
November 30, 2011, 01:53AM
Thanks Jane & Sarah for your insightful interpretation of this quote, both recognizing people's attachment to the past, as well as exploring what it means to be optimistic about the future.

I wonder what ways there are to honor & build on heritage, while creating new revitalization opportunities.

Hopefully something to be explored in concepting.
November 11, 2011, 02:01AM
Thanks Vincent for sharing. I also like the way you summarize the different themes. I agree with Sarah that the reference to places that used to be is very sad. Yet, the attachment to the community is also an emergent theme. It reminded me 2 other inspirations - http://www.openideo.com/open/vibrant-cities/inspiration/the-domino-effect-when-one-city-falls.../
http://www.openideo.com/open/vibrant-cities/inspiration/lemonade-detroit-making-hope-porn-and-inviting-people-to-become-producers-at-a-1-frame/
 that showed the emotional attachment to a place, but also the inspiring power and willingness to act it can provide. I might sound too optimistic (and I don't have any experience doing social work) but based on some of these inspirations, and some of your quotes, and also the many examples of people engaged in the process of redesigning their communities, neighborhoods or cities, I'm wondering if one of the key thing is not to create the conditions - resources, support, faith - for people to give it a try.
November 09, 2011, 08:52PM
very useful post!
November 09, 2011, 01:55AM
Go the Mighty Vince! Fab unpacking of insight here – looking forward to onwards discussion on all the brilliant points you've raised.
November 09, 2011, 01:42AM
Great inspiration Vincent! I love the way you have summarized their stories into a few key points. Concise, but impactful. Thanks :)
November 09, 2011, 01:40AM
Thanks Vincent for sharing this! The excerpts are very touching... The first one about people giving directions using venues that don't exist anymore strikes me the most. How long can people still keep being optimist and attached to the memory of what used to be their city and their community?
close

Login

Forgot my password?

New user? Sign up!